There are 5 choices, 5 votes for likgaribe's debate

Are the jews the oldest existing tribe in the world, , and is egypt the oldest existing nation?

“I stumbled upon a mystery without a solution, a mystery so immense that I gave up trying to find an explanation because the whole mystery defied belief. The mystery was the survival of the Jews…I couldn’t understand how these people had endured as the great people they were…”

My topic is based on this quote I picked up from a book recently. I want to know two things:  Which is the oldest surviving tribe in the world?  Which is the oldest surviving country in the world?

I don’t believe the answers are obvious; there are so many tribes that are not necessarily popular or well known as the Jews for example. I hope that this is a learning experience especially as I hope to hear from people all over the world.

Please do not turn this into a tribal issue or worse still a religious one, this isn’t about whose tribe s better or anything like that? So if you happen to know of any old tribes, and an old country please submit them.


  • Sumer is oldest

    No! Sumer in present Iraq is the oldest (3500 BC) and Egypt is next (3100 BC). Abraham, the founder of the Jewish nation, didn’t leave Sumer until 2000 BC

    Voted for by nanrek.
  • :

  • denial

    People who live in egypt are closer to denial

    Voted for by grant.
  • :

  • why are you so ignorant

    that is a dumb question your coming from the ignorant standpoint of a christian who has read no historical text other than the bible. Go do some research there are dozens of cultures and yeligions that predate the very EXISTENCE of Christianity. In addition Christianity stole many of it's books from other cultures to draw people in from other cultures so that they could control as many people as possible. That is why most of the old testament is jewish text. that is why the oldest book of the bible is a sumerian tale. In addition to the book of Job, the concept of a part god part human offspring was also stole from the Sumerians. The whole judeochristin mythos is pre date by many centuries by eastern religions and many other regional religions that were wiped out by people from one branchof christians or another. There is much more to this but I'll stop there. Go take a college level history class.

    Voted for by jackgillespie.
  • :

  • the path to wisdom is too acknowledge how little you truly know.

    jackgillespie thanx for calling me ignorant, in case you did not know great wisdom comes from knowing how ignorant you are,

    the topic qn, is just that a qn, not a reflection of my personal beleifs on the issue but an opening to allow people like you to educate the rest of us ignorant people, but you obviosly feel very strongly on the issue. thanx for the comment. i suspected what you are saying but i was hoping that i would here from other people about how old their tribes are, or their countries.

    Voted for by likgaribe.
  • :

  • here we go, im not really adding anything :P

    I'm pretty sure that the oldest 'civilization' is egypt, but the oldest 'tribe' would be the bushmen, or, arguably, the indigeneous people of australia.

    Voted for by Cornilius.
  • :

  •  

    None of the choices fit your opinion?  Add one →