There are 9 choices, 13 votes for radioboy's debate

Why does usa circumcise boys?

Over the past sixty years circumcision of males that are neither Jewish or Moslem gained popularity in English speaking countries. Since then it was waned and all but disappeared in all except USA. Most hospitals still offer the mutilation, insurance will pay and doctors do.

The backlash to SAVE circumcision has raised many strawman arguments such as hygiene, STD, urinary infections as a frantic effort to keep the mutilations alive.


  • No harm like with female circumcision

    I’ve heard some people claim it is more pleasurable to be circumcised, but basically I fail to see what the big difference could be – its just a little flap of skin

    23%  Voted for by Kevin, chibi-kaiyaska, chuloputas.
  • :

  • Three Reasons or So

    It started as an ancient religious practice. I do not know the full significance.

    In the last century, it was considered more sanitary. It was still an on going religious practice.

    Now I understand it may heighten sexual stimulation.

    There’s three, there may be other reasons.

    Andy

    23%  Voted for by Andy Stephenson, Liao Oniisan, chuloputas.
  • :

  • ***

    I wouldn’t have it any other way….

    15%  Voted for by joshuada, chuloputas.
  • :

  • Better Sex

    It certainly improves sex a lot. I was circumcised by free choice aged 44 and I'm now 60 so i should know more than 99% of men.

    Voted for by chuloputas.
  • :

  • Some reasons

    First of all Jesus christ was circumcised, and seeing as how the US is called like the “christian nation” (I myself being a christian). Actually I think it reduces feeling. Not quite sure i’ll have to go look it up. ~jazzy

    Voted for by Goddess of Chat.
  • :

  • Social Mechanisms

    People forget the original reasons, and begin calling them ‘strawmen’. Such things continue to mindlessly happen because the social structure has been set up for it, and if it’s a trivial matter, no one cares enough to re-question of alter the practice. I’m sure if a profit could be made by ending it, someone would be trying!

    Voted for by wbiro.
  • :

  • Uncircumcised

    is nasty. I am so glad to be with a circumcised boy, I would hate it any other way.

    Voted for by newmiracle87.
  • :

  • The Jewish Reason

    the first time they talk about it in the old testiment was when God tells Abraham to do it to himself and that all males should henseforth as an "everlasting coventant with God."

    so thats where it started it think. i personally prefer it coz its a tradition and it looks better.

    Voted for by Rineai.
  • :

  • ?

    why does everyone call circumcision "mutilation"?

  • :

  •  

    None of the choices fit your opinion?  Add one →