There are 4 choices, 7 votes for Kazrith's debate

Elderly Catholic Couple Denied Communion

Image and video hosting by TinyPic

Nova Scotia, Canada

a Gay elderly couple have been denied communion at th Roman Catholic church unless they agree to remain celibate.
Communion waffers are considered the body and blood of Christ. to Catholics receiving communion is one of the most scared rights and this couple have been denied it.
the couple posted a picture of their wedding in a newspaper (seen above) and the archbishop of the church saw this and they have now decided to deny them communion.

is it right to deny homosexuals communion when others receive this right even when their sins are known?

http://www.ctv.ca/servlet/ArticleNews/story/CTVNews/20061210/gays_communion_061210/20061210?hub=TopStories
  • exiled to rome
    strangely i agree with the catholic church. just as it is not appropriate for the catholic bishops to have an opinion one way or another if i wish to be married by the state. i should not seek to influence the catholic church one way or another on how they see fit to police their faith. i must however stop to ponder these inconsistencies. if these two gay men are worthy of what amounts to excommunication then why is cardinal law( the cardinal who oversaw the reassigning of the pedophile priests in Boston)is still receiving communion and is now part of the collage of cardinals?
    to this day the Boston diocese has still not come clean about where all the pedophile priests are so i must assume that they are still out there and still having sex with alter boys. shouldn't those alter boys be refused communion for leading those good Shepherds away from their flocks?
    42%  Voted for by bob2314, Weydon, petethemeat.
  • :

  • SMUT
    Just look at that hideous photo of them? This really emphasizes the widely known FACT that homosexuality is all about hot, freaky-monkey passion and--most heinously--LUST.

    There is no love between those 2 men. If you look at it and tell me you see anything aside from that "Homosexual Passion" (known to be contagious to the moron kids that mimic-for-life the first same-sex act they see), that you see some sweet old couple that really and truly loves each other deeply--you're a liar. A liar and recruiter to homosexuals. These lusty, disgusting men have their choice to be with each other rather than the NATURAL choice of women (don't bother me with the semantics of these men being so old that their being with women wouldn't make babies either!) obviously makes them excluded from participation in the receiving of Christ. Take one final look at that SMUT, and tell me that's the kind of emotion Christ would like. Christ taught us LOVE, tolerance, and peace--not whatever THAT is.
    28%  Voted for by Weydon, bob2314.
  • :

  • depends
    is it right to deny homosexuals communion when others receive this right even when their sins are known?

    depends on what the Catholic faith stands for in reference to communion as a whole.If they disagree they can always choose to belong somewhere else.
    Voted for by Energizer Bunny.
  • :

  • on the one hand
    as a Christian, I cannot in good conscience condone homosexuality, so I can see where the Catholics are coming from on this issue. However as an Adventist , I feel that the Catholic church is a heresy, the "Little horn of the great Beast" mentioned in the book of Daniel, so I tend not to like anything they stand for.
    Voted for by NeferMaatNetjer.
  • :

  •  

    None of the choices fit your opinion?  Add one →